Major revision minor revision 違い

Author: mgat

August undefined, 2024

Web13 mei 2024 · 超Minor revisionからのUnder review. 論文投稿記. Elsevier系列の雑誌に投稿していた論文の1st decisionが返ってきた。. レビュワーは2人で、どちらの方も単語や … WebThe journal’s editor sent your manuscript to two or more reviewers, and at least one of them felt that substantial changes were needed. However, some added work and/or explanation can resolve these issues. That’s interpreted as major revisions. That’s why you’re still in the game. You can make it better.

publications - Is it a minor or major revision, if only one of the ...

Web답이 딱 나옵니다. major revision을 주는 경우는 reviewer가 생각하기에 논문이 전체적으로 새로운 것이 있는 듯하지만, 아주 중요한 point가 빠져있다고 판단했을때 이지요. 이 경우 지적 받은 사항을 아주 잘 대응을 할때에만 좋은 성과가 있을 듯합니다. 혹은 reviewer가 ... Web15 dec. 2024 · バージョンの概念とはまた異なりますが、一般的にエディションの違いは有効機能の違いとして現れます。例えば、こちらを見てみて下さい。 vSphere 6.x の各 … giftcode gunpow 2019

Journal Said “Major Revisions” Needed? Here’s What to Do

Web13 mrt. 2024 · Minor revision: The paper is almost accepted. Only a few minor changes or clarifications are needed. Receiving this output from good journals is very rare. It happens in less than 10% of submissions. Major revision: The paper could be accepted after some significant changes. WebMinor revision usually implies that the reviewers (and the editor) think that authors can correct the paper in a way that will address all of the concerns, and the reviewers not need to see the paper again before publication. Web22 nov. 2024 · Are you being asked for a minor revision? If so, it would be reasonable for the Editor to expect that a revised manuscript could be submitted within the next week or two. If you have been asked for a major revision, expect that it will take significantly more time to complete. The Editor will not be happy if you resubmit your work within hours ... fry night funkin mods jogar

How to Write a Good Revision Letter - César Soto Valero

Web31 jul. 2024 · メジャーな雑誌に投稿し2か月ほどでmajor revisionの判定が帰ってきました。. ほとんど答えられる内容だったため、しっかり返答を行ったうえでreviseを行いました。. reviseして3週間ほどでwith editorからDecision in Processにステータスが変更となりました。. これは再 ... WebIt is very possible to get a minor revision as a first decision, and then major revision as second decision, and finally a rejection. This can be heart-breaking to authors. gift code chimeralandWebProgramName version major.minor.build.revision. major: For me is the current project I am working on. The number will not change until I start a new project of the same program name. This means I will literally be writing a new program of the same gender (example: access v1 - access v-2 - access v-3 * all the same program but completely rewritten). gift code for my origines

"Web12 nov. 2024 · Months later I received a "Minor Revision". One of the 3 reviewers asked to add a future research direction section. The other asked to correct the number of a … " - Major revision minor revision 違い

Major revision minor revision 違い

What exactly is the build number in MAJOR.MINOR.BUILDNUMBER.REVISION

Web6 jun. 2024 · See the following differences between minor and major revisions: What Is a Minor Revision? Minor revisions are those that do not change the risk level of the … Web大修和小修，分别叫做major revision 和 minor revision,其实代表的是审稿人的一种倾向. major的话代表这个paper审稿人觉得问题比较大，但也不是无可挽救，只是需要对文章进行比较大的改动，一般审稿人提的意见也是比较核心的，就是他认为你给的论据实际上没办法 ...

Did you know?

Web10 sep. 2024 · the minor revisions being changed into major revisions is uncommon, but given the seemingly poor quality of the reviews it is understandable if the editor read the … Web9 feb. 2024 · major revision（メジャーリビジョン）の場合、minor revision（マイナーリビジョン）と比べて、修正箇所が多く、修正内容も複雑です。さらに、査読者への回答 …

Web13 mei 2024 · 生物系論文で、minor revisionからの採択率はどれくらいですかまたdecisionまでどれくらいでしょうか minor revision後の修正原稿を年末に出しました. 農学、バイオテクノロジー. 今年の3月下旬に論文を投稿しましたが、9月半ばになっても一度も査読結果が返って ... WebA major revision often requires more substantive changes prior to being appropriate for publication. Major revisions are almost always sent back to reviewers for a re-review to …

Web7 apr. 2016 · The exact semantics of major or minor revisions will depend on the journal - at some journals, a minor revision will not be externally reviewed any more, while a major revision will. At others, the difference … Web1 okt. 2012 · To my experience, major revision in general leads to the acceptance of a manuscript reviewed and re-reviewed for several rounds. Minor revision may undergo …

Web著者は、この期間が長く感じることでしょう。また、ジャーナルから来たメールを開けるときは、相当の緊張感があるに違いありません。多くのジャーナルからの返事は、以下 …

Web5 dec. 2024 · 質問: Revise を投稿したが Editor と Associate Editor の評価のみで Major Revisionとなったケース. 質問の内容 -. ある雑誌に投稿，RevisionにてReviewerのコメントに対応し，再投稿しました．数日後，Editor とAssociate Editorの評価のみでMajor Revisionとなりましたがコメントが ... giftcode fpt playWeb12 nov. 2024 · Months later I received a "Minor Revision". One of the 3 reviewers asked to add a future research direction section. The other asked to correct the number of a certain section. The corrections were easy and I resubmitted the article. Surprisingly, today I received a "Major Revision", which is quite unlikely. gift code desert island survivalWeb22 feb. 2024 · Whether a revised manuscript will be sent for another round of reviews is the sole decision of the handling editor; while it's virtually guaranteed for a major revision, it may or may not happen for a minor revision based on the specific comments, the responses to them, and how confident the editor feels about evaluating themselves … gift code honkai impact 3 terbaruWeb19 mei 2024 · まずmajor revisionに関わる上記3つの要求に回答した上で、minorな内容についても基本は全て回答していくことになります。 minorな内容については全てを査読 … giftcode gunpow 2018WebHome. Decision types on journal articles. After your article has been reviewed, you will receive an email with a first decision on the article. IOP has a range of different decisions you could receive and these are outlined below. You will see what each decision type is and what it means for you and your article. giftcode fun knight fry night funkin mod neoWeb大幅な改訂（Major Revision）：大幅な改訂が必要。小幅な改訂（Minor Revision）：小幅な改訂が必要。掲載拒否（Reject）になるときもある。 ②心持ち（私の場合）掲載拒否でなければOK。改訂すれば投稿論文が受理されるということだから。 fry night funkin navegador